
“No advice fee” does not describe every payment
An appointment can produce no bill to the client while still being remunerated by the insurer. FINMA says non-tied insurance intermediaries must tell clients about all types of remuneration they receive from insurers or third parties in connection with the service. It also requires understandable information before the contract is concluded. Asking about remuneration is therefore a normal part of comparing a pillar 3a insurance offer. It does not establish the amount of a commission or mean a commission-funded product is automatically unsuitable.
Put three columns beside the quote
First record fees you would pay directly and what the advice agreement covers. Then ask what remuneration the adviser receives from the provider or third parties and how it is determined. Finally read the policy costs: acquisition, administration, risk cover and investments, as applicable. These columns may be connected without being identical. A commission is not necessarily another amount to add on top of costs already described; avoid counting the same cost twice. Equally, no separate invoice is not evidence that the arrangement has no costs.
An example without invented tariffs
Two proposals each involve CHF 300 in monthly payments and death cover. Under assumption A, the provider remunerates the adviser. Under B, there is a separate advice fee. That difference alone does not tell you which is cheaper. Request the same protection, duration, guaranteed amounts and cost horizon for both. If you might reduce contributions, compare the values and consequences of changing each policy at the same point. The CHF 300 is not all invested savings if it also funds insurance and charges.
Questions that matter when replacing a policy
If you already have a contract, ask how keeping, amending or replacing it changes remuneration and costs. Check any advice agreement separately: its purpose, price, acceptance date and termination terms. Asking for a surrender quote is not automatically an instruction to cancel. Understand remuneration alongside the benefits you could lose, the amount transferable and underwriting for any new cover. A remuneration disclosure answers who is paid; it does not by itself settle whether replacing the policy serves your needs.
Retain a readable record
File the intermediary’s status and remuneration information, any advice agreement and the product cost document with the dated quote. Ask for a written explanation if a formula leaves you unable to understand who pays what. The aim is to compare the solution and the incentives around it. A registration number or a past-performance figure cannot provide that answer by itself.
Compare the service promised as well
Ask what is included after signing: policy follow-up, help with changes and any agreed review frequency. Distinguish those commitments from services that may be charged separately later. Comparing remuneration arrangements becomes more useful when you also know what work each payment funds and who is responsible for doing it. Keep those promises alongside the quote so a future request for an additional fee can be checked against the service originally agreed.
Sources & further reading
FINMA — Obligations des intermédiaires : information et rémunération