
Identify who makes the tax claim
The Federal Tax Administration’s Circular 18a contains a specific rule for securities held through a bank pillar 3a foundation. The foundation that opened the individual custody account for the saver is entitled to reclaim withholding tax deducted from securities income. It submits the application to the FTA. The annual statement must explain that the pillar 3a holder has no personal right to that refund. This rule concerns that pension structure; it does not describe every investment you might hold in a private account.
An example separating three figures
Suppose a pillar 3a statement shows CHF 1,000 of gross investment income and CHF 350 of withholding, using an illustrative assumption of Swiss withholding at 35%. The initial net receipt would be CHF 650. Those figures do not let the saver personally claim CHF 350 on a tax return as if they had received a private dividend. Ask the foundation how the refund application and its outcome are reflected in the portfolio records. Do not assume an immediate refund to your current account or a guaranteed date for a credit to pillar 3a.
Separate investment income from contributions
A distribution, a withholding refund obtained by the foundation or a change in fund value does not automatically become a new personal contribution. To check the annual ceiling, use the payments providers certify as contributions. To assess performance, ask how income, charges and delayed credits are recorded. One statement may help you track investments and establish a payment, but its numbers answer different questions. Keep the contribution history alongside the transaction history rather than substituting one for the other.
What to ask if the statement seems incomplete
Ask whether the line concerns Swiss or foreign withholding, which investment and period it relates to and who may request a refund. The rule discussed here does not provide a general right to recover every foreign deduction. If assets moved between two foundations, retain the closing and opening statements and ask which provider will follow up a pending transaction. A later credit is not necessarily a performance error, but it should be possible to reconcile it.
Check before completing the return
File the pillar 3a contribution certificate separately from investment information. Do not copy income from a pension statement into the private securities schedule without checking the account type and the tax authority’s instructions. If a credit or claim has been counted twice, ask for the relevant document to be corrected. The aim is to trace each amount to its actual treatment, rather than confusing the pension arrangement’s tax treatment with an additional personal refund. Keep the foundation’s written explanation with the relevant statement. It helps distinguish an item still being processed from a figure already settled in the account.
Match the document to the question
Before a tax appointment, separate the contribution certificate, portfolio statement and foundation’s explanation of the withholding item. That lets you ask a focused question without presenting the same amount several times as a personal deduction. Mark any unresolved credit as pending rather than treating it as money already available.
Sources & further reading
AFC / FTA — Circulaire 18a, section 10